Last week I had a genuinely fine day. Nothing broke, nobody was upset with me, no inbox disaster, no “we need to talk” text. And by 6pm I caught myself thinking, quite seriously, “okay, what am I forgetting.”
Nothing. I wasn’t forgetting anything. I just didn’t know what to do with a day that wasn’t asking anything of me.
I think a lot of us are like this and don’t really clock it until it’s pointed out. We spend so much of our time in some version of “waiting for the other shoe to drop” that when the shoe just… doesn’t drop, we get restless instead of relieved.
It’s not that we enjoy stress. Nobody’s out here rooting for bad news. But bracing for it becomes such a habit that when there’s nothing to brace against, something feels off. Like standing on a moving walkway that’s stopped moving. You still lean forward out of muscle memory.
Bracing is a habit that pays out either way
Part of it is just that bracing has worked for us before. You expect the worst, and when the worst doesn’t happen, you feel like you dodged something, even prepared for it. When it does happen, at least you saw it coming. Either way bracing pays out. So the brain keeps doing it, because why would it stop doing the thing that keeps working. It doesn’t really occur to it to ask “but what if there’s nothing to brace for right now.”
You can see this in small, dumb ways if you pay attention. Someone takes a while to reply to a text and your stomach does a little dip before your brain even finishes the thought “they’re probably just busy.” The dip comes first. The reasonable explanation shows up late, almost apologetically, after the damage is done. That’s not you being dramatic, that’s just the system doing its job a little too early, a little too often.
And it’s not only about disaster-proofing the big stuff either. It shows up in tiny ways like double-checking a sent email for the third time, replaying a totally normal conversation for hours, packing three backup chargers for a two-hour flight. None of that is really about the email or the flight. It’s the mind keeping itself occupied, staying “useful,” because an idle brain apparently feels riskier to it than an overworked one.
The brain isn’t great at recognizing safety
Here’s the part I find kind of funny in hindsight: the brain is actually not that good at clocking safety. It’ll spot a threat from a mile away, no training required, that’s basically day-one wiring. But “everything is fine” doesn’t come with the same alarm system. It’s not a signal, it’s an absence of signal, and absence doesn’t really register as anything. You have to sort of consciously go “oh wait, this is good, I should just let this be good” which is a weirdly effortful thing to do for something that’s supposed to feel effortless.
There’s almost no vocabulary for it either, if you think about it. We’ve got a hundred words for different flavors of stress like overwhelmed, frazzled, on edge, spiraling. Ask someone to describe calm, though, and most people just shrug and say “good, I guess.” Peace doesn’t have texture the way anxiety does. It’s just quiet. And quiet, to a mind trained on noise, can start to feel like something’s missing rather than something’s working.
So the brain goes looking for something to solve
So what happens instead, at least for me, is I go looking for a problem. Not on purpose. I’ll reread a message for a tone that almost certainly wasn’t there. Or remember some small thing from months ago and decide it needs sorting out right now, this evening, no particular reason. Give me a free hour with nothing pressing and I will, apparently, invent something pressing. It’s less “main character self-sabotage” and more like a dog with nothing to chase running in circles instead.
Sometimes it’s subtler than manufacturing a crisis, it’s just refusing to fully sit in the good moment. You’re on a nice trip and you catch yourself thinking about the flight back before you’ve even unpacked. You get good news and immediately start bracing for the catch. It’s not that you don’t believe the good thing is real, it’s more that some part of you doesn’t trust it to stay real, so it keeps one foot out the door just in case.
What I’m trying instead
I don’t think there’s a clean fix for this, and I’d be suspicious of anyone who said there was. But naming it helps a bit. When I catch myself doing the thing like turning a calm evening into a manufactured emergency, I try to just say to myself, out loud sometimes, “there’s nothing wrong right now.” Not in a mantra-y way. More like pointing at it and going, yeah, I see what you’re doing.
And then, if I can manage it, I let the evening stay boring. Let the peace be peace without making it earn its keep or prove it’s not a trick. It’s allowed to just be a Tuesday where nothing happens.
Still feels a little suspicious though. I’m not going to pretend it doesn’t.
Have something to share? Submit a guest post. Click here for more information.
Join The Conversation